Expand this Topic clickable element to expand a topic
OSA Publishing
Reviewer Certification

6. Assessing Presentation


First Impression

First impressions are crucial for readers. Consider the beginning of the paper you are reviewing.

  • Are the title and abstract accurate – in other words, do they reflect the study clearly and realistically? Are they concise and interesting?
  • Is the introduction accessible and readable? Is the thesis (or hypothesis) immediately clear?
  • Does the introduction sufficiently cover (and reference) the existing literature that acts as a foundation for the authors’ study?

If the title, abstract, or introduction could be improved, then detail your recommendations to the authors in your review comments.

Select as filters

    Select Topics Cancel
    © Copyright 2019 | The Optical Society. All Rights Reserved